Posts

Unfulfilled Deconstructions of Heroes: How Studios Keep Failing

Image
 It currently seems to be the trend in media to have beloved heroes reduced to the lowest of lows. See how Luke becomes a miserable grump in The Last Jedi , how Picard feels like a washed up failure in Picard , how Batman has become a psychopath in Batman vs Superman , and how Capaldi's doctor in Dr. Who became a miserable jerk who treated everyone around him like garbage for all of what I saw of series 8. In theory, there is nothing inherently wrong with these ideas but the execution consistently fails.  The first problem is how these pieces of media seem fundamentally uninterested in establishing how the characters got to this point. Luke was always defined as someone who failed. Throughout the OT, he is failing at things, whether it be needing to be saved by the Sand People, or failing to lift the X-Wing without Yoda's assistance. Yet ultimately, he overcomes these failures to become a Jedi. What this shows is this a man who will respond with failure with a determination to...

Raya and the Last Dragon: A Beautiful Failure

Image
  I have been far from the biggest fan of the films from the so-called "Disney Rebirth." I probably thought Tangled   was the best as its humor felt the most organic and it boasted truly memorable characters whether they be endearing, Rapunzel and Maximus the horse, or menacing, Mother Gothel. Other films, however, like Frozen or Moana boasted exemplary animation but were hampered by meandering plots, thin characters, and often teeth grindingly bad humor. Raya of the Last Dragon definitely suffers from this last problem, while admittedly continuing the trend of absolutely gorgeous animation. Many of the humor sequences do not work because too often it feels like the film is saying "stop, let's have an extended comic sketch" and thus it feels awkward. It also feels awkward because the world of the film is a dark dystopian one so random comic intervals feel like they're there because they're expected rather than that they should be there.  Nevertheless, th...

Why AOC sharing her story threatens people.

Image
  There has been a severe backlash towards Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez, or AOC, sharing the story of her sexual assault and how she threatened during the terrorist attack on the Capital Building. Just last night the hashtag "AOC lied" was trending on social media. This toxic ideology can be traced back to two popular creation stories. Think of Adam and Eve and how it is Eve who responsible for the end of Paradise because of her tricking Adam into eating the forbidden fruit. Think of Pandora's box, and how Pandora's inquisitiveness leads to her opening the box and dooming humanity. These creation stories establish two precedents that too often guide our society: women are deceitful and women should be quiet. And what do you know: the accusations against AOC are that she is lying and that she should shut up.  Pandora's dooming of humanity These toxic ideals reverberate throughout our media. Think of how often you have heard authoritative women be called "bitches...

Years and Years: A show for our world

Image
 After really loving the Davies era of Dr. Who, I decided to seek out other works of his. It was then that I found a recent project of his, Years and Years . Like so much of Davies' work, this show captures what media  should do but rarely does. It probes our world and is not afraid in making the viewer uncomfortable while doing so. It also somehow juggles a dark cynical portrait of humanity while never losing faith in our capacity to be better. It is a special show I could not recommend enough.  In this series, Davies casts his net wide as he touches on things like technology, immigration, and the rise of fascism. His treatment of technology is fascinating as in many ways it could be read as a repudiation of the popular Black Mirror. While that show almost always shows technology as a force that will end up destroying our lives, Davies prefers a more nuanced portrait. A character seeks to be transhuman, meaning she wants to merge with a computer, and this character ends ...

Sci-Fi Saviors: Russel T. Davies and Michael Piller

Image
 Some of my favorite shows growing up were the Star Trek shows as supervised by Michael Piller or made in the legacy of Michael Piller. I characterize this era from TNG season 3, when Michael Piller took over as a show-runner, to the end of DS9, the departure of Ira Stephen Behr, the last hand picked show-runner by Michael Piller. These shows were strongly interested in character and exploring fascinating thematic ideas and have played a critical role in shaping who I am. Dr . Who is a show I barely knew until recently but over the last few months I have been watching every episode of the Davies Era from Rose onwards I have really come to love the show and the warm humanism embodied in the episodes. This post is a tribute to these two men.  When Michael Piller took over TNG, the show was frankly in disarray. To be charitable, the first two seasons had been messes with no real clear vision and characters who seemed overly stiff both literally and figuratively. Scripts often se...

My Favorite Films of All Time: Conspiracy

Image
  The film, Conspiracy, depicts the events of the Wannsee Conference where the infamous Final Solution was revealed to various members of the German bureaucracy for the first time. The film does a good job of presenting the events in a way that aligns with the historical truth but its greatest strength is how it fully shows how complicit the people involved were, as even those who were against genocide were still highly reprehensible, such as Wilhem Stuckart. Adding to the film’s power is Kenneth Branagh’s performance as Reinhard Heydrich and Stanley Tucci’s performance as Adolf Eichmann which are both excellent and bring these people to life with frightening realism. The frightening realism is most realized in the final scenes when everybody goes home like they have just discussed a game of golf. The film is interested in painting a portrait of a society that is rotten to the core and in that, the film succeeds beautifully. The main content of what was presented at the Wannsee...

Long Day's Journey into Night or Why I quit Star Trek

  Star Trek: Discovery launched on September 24, 2017  marking the first time Trek was on the small screen in over ten years. I went in with hope and optimism as I was encouraged by the show's decision to have a black woman be the show's lead for the first time in the franchise's history. Those feeling of hope and optimism are very hard to remember now as over the last three years, which have felt like 30 years, my interest in discussing Discovery, and the other CBS Trek shows, have been slowly crushed.  Soon after Discovery aired, there began to be a wave of bad faith critics who ranted about how Trek had been taken over by "wokeness" or "SJWs" which was obviously nonsense. Nevertheless despite my disagreements with these bad faith critics I did think there were major problems with the story and sometimes acting in Discovery. I hoped to be able to air my critiques and offer good faith criticism that would represent a counterbalance to the overwhelming w...

Alive in Our Minds

Image
Is anything truly not alive? I often hear things, and have even said myself, like "it's only a movie" but is that really true? I would argue no for one simple reason. While much of the media we watch might not have actually happened, our memories and our emotions that we feel are very real to us. I would argue that this is why remakes or bad sequels hurt so much. We remember how we felt when we saw the original piece of media, and thus to see something so similar but just off, is painful. It is like seeing a pod person of a beloved family member. Our memories come back to us but in a distorted reflection. Nowhere was that more painfully evident for me than when I was watching the live action Beauty and the Beast. I would hear the words of the songs, and the words would remind me of the joy I feel watching the animated film. But then the flat autotuned of Emma Watson would kick in and that joy would distort into revulsion.  How I saw the Live action Beauty and the Beast Th...

6 historical biopics we need

Image
 As a white cisgender man, I possesses the privilege of being able to see myself reflected in historical media, indeed all media, consistently. This is a privilege many do not possess so I would like to spot like some dream films/shows that could offer a more diverse view of the historical world. 1. Baron Von Steuben was instrumental to turning the tide of the American Revolution. His training of the Continental Army is widely credited with turning them from a motley crew into a seasoned fighting force capable of combatting the British on an even playing field. Steuben was also most likely gay and it is highly likely he engaged in a romantic relationship with fellow officer, Benjamin Walker. Even today, a common myth about Gay men is that they are not strong and indeed to be called "gay" is still an epithet amongst many straight people. Therefore, how better to challenge that preposterous notion than to make a film about the man responsible for molding the first American Army...

Failed Empowerment: Why Mulan 2020 is a Potemkin Village

Image
 Mulan 2020 had a lot of controversy surrounding its release due to its star expressing support for the authoritarian Chinese Government  and the filmmaker's decision to film in some areas where the Chinese concentration camps for the Uighurs populations are . Beyond all of that, however, there is also the fact that the film is shockingly regressive compared to its animated predecessor which came out 22 years prior. The animated film has a heavy "queer" subtext that is omitted form the live action version. Second, the animated film suggests one can be strong in ways that defy traditional ideas of masculinity. The live action film, however, seems to believe that strength can only come from traditional ideas of masculinity. One of the most powerful scenes from the 1998 film is the song Reflection. When one listens to the lyrics, one can see how they have a far greater poignancy than just being about a woman who does not fit in. Rather they are for anyone who does not fit i...

Breaking Free: Why All That Heaven Allows is still a masterpiece 65 years later.

Image
Whether we like it or not, media is tremendously important to shaping how we see the world. Thus, it is important to value films that upend traditional views of the world and offer us alternatives to how we can conduct ourselves. All That Heaven allows is one of those films. It upends what it means to be an older woman and also what means to be a man in ways that are still timely and still critical.  Our media typically does not portray women as frequently with a 2018 study finding that women made up 35% of the speaking  parts . Perhaps most soberingly it is actually an improvement over 2017 where women made up just 24% of the speaking parts. Furthermore, when we look at our media we rarely see films that deal with domestic problems and the entrapment one can feel when society says one is no longer relevant. A simple google search reveals that many women over 40 feel this particular problem.  We see these issues throughout the film, as Jane Wyman's character, Cary Scott, ...

Balance of Character: A Review of Balance of Terror

Image
 "Had he and I but met/by some old Ancient Inn/We should have sat us down to wet/Right many a nipperkin/But ranged as infantry/And staring face to face/I shot at him as he at me/And killed him in his place." These lines come from Thomas Hardy's 1902 poem, The Man he Killed, and offers a commentary on the then raging Boer War. The poem is a rumination on war and how the people who kill one another are not so different. It is that theme that runs throughout the Star Trek episode, Balance of Terror, which over 50 years later still holds up as one of the masterpieces of the Star Trek Franchise.  This theme of recognizing the humanity of our common enemy is apparent right away in the episode with this line by Spock: "Earth believes the Romulans to be warlike, cruel, treacherous, and only the Romulans know what they think of Earth." Through this line, the episode instantly making clear that there is going to be greater nuance in this episode than hunt down the evil mo...

Internet Demagogues and Propaganda

Image
The Rise of the internet has also seen a rise in internet demagogues. People who are predicated on spreading rumors and continually hating on things. The policies they follow are adherent to many of the masters of propaganda. Lenin argued that skillful propaganda is not " calculated . . . to convince [or to] correct the mistake of the opponent, but to destroy him, to wipe his organization off the face of the earth. This wording is indeed of such a nature, as to evoke the worst thoughts, the worst suspicions about the opponent."  (Michiko Kakutani,  The Death of Truth,  136) And it is that rhetoric we see when we look at the internet rhetoric used again and again at say Rian Johnson. It is not enough to dislike The Last Jedi. Instead even Johnson's own name must be destroyed, as a frequent moniker for him is Ruin Johnson. A google search finds endless posts all about Rian Johnson but by referring to him as the name, Ruin Johnson. Indeed there is even an entire twitter...

Rebounding from Failure

 I am taking a break from discussing media to write something personal. Life can be brutal and life will give you setbacks. I would argue that is inevitable. What I would also argue, however, is that what truly matters most is how we respond to it. I know this because my high school years were defined by huge setbacks. I was homeschooled until my Junior year of High School and so simply going to school was a tremendous cultural shock for me. The first day I was lost and late to practically every class. By Lunch time I was thoroughly miserable and by the evening I was huddled underneath a blanket whispering to myself repeatedly "I wish I could back in time to when I was seven." High school would only get worse from there. I do not want to act as if there were only bad times because that would be greatly misleading. I did well in my history classes, indeed I got an 115 in my 12th grade history class, and met some excellent teachers who I greatly respected and still enjoy commun...

The Last Jedi and The Rise of Skywalker: Two films or Two Children Fighting over Their Favorite Toys?

Image
 Much ink has been spilt about the quality or lack thereof when it comes to the two films, Star Wars: The Last Jedi and Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. This is not one of those articles. This is more of a analysis of how the directors responded to one another and the puzzling fan reactions to those responses.   It is inarguable that the Last Jedi chose to go its own way when it came to key story beats of the Force Awakens as Rian Johnson reportedly threw out JJ Abrams' Star Wars Episode 8 script . Essentially Rian Johnson snatched Abram's toys and said "I want to play this way." Johnson's choosing to ignore Abrams is apparent right away. The Force Awakens ends with a dramatic scene of Rey holding out Luke's lightsaber to him as the force theme plays. Clearly Abrams intended this to be a scene of immense gravitas. In the Last Jedi, however, when we pick up with that scene he has Luke casually throw the lightsaber away. Now, whether one likes that storytelling...